A. Marchand et M. Wapler, EFFECT OF PERSONALITY-DISORDERS ON RESPONSE TO BEHAVIORAL-COGNITIVE THERAPY OF PANIC DISORDER WITH AGORAPHOBIA, Canadian journal of psychiatry, 38(3), 1993, pp. 163-166
This study measures the effect of personality disorders on the efficac
y of treatment of agoraphobia. Forty-one patients suffering from panic
disorder with agoraphobia are evaluated for the presence of a persona
lity disorder (according to DSM-III-R criteria) before the onset of tr
eatment. The treatment consists in 14 sessions of behavioural cognitiv
e therapy. Various measures of agoraphobic avoidance are obtained befo
re (pre-test) and after the end of treatment (post-test, three month f
ollow-up). Effect of treatment reaches statistical and clinical signif
icance for all patients. Grouping of patients according to presence or
absence of personality disorder shows no significant difference betwe
en the groups before or after treatment on scores of agoraphobia. A su
bgroup of patients with dependent personality disorder does not differ
on measures of agoraphobic avoidance from patients without personalit
y disorders or with other personality disorders. The discussion points
out methodological limitations, differences in our study from other s
tudies regarding the effect of personality on the treatment outcome of
panic disorder with agoraphobia, as well as possibilities for future
studies.