We have carried out an arrested development study on model thermally d
eveloped photographic materials (TDPM) based on silver carboxylates. F
rom both TEM and x-ray diffraction analysis of the media at various st
ages of development, we infer that (1) during initiation of developmen
t small, spheroidal silver(0) particles form; (2) over the course of t
he development reaction, the number of silver(0) spheroids increases,
but not their average size; (3) this process requires secondary nuclea
tion of the silver(0) phase-forming reaction by an as-yet unestablishe
d mechanism; and (4) above some threshold concentration, whose establi
shment corresponds to the onset of the continuation stage of developme
nt, these spheroids aggregate to form the light-absorbing particles co
mprising the TDPM image. Development kinetics of full-soap and half-so
ap systems were studied experimentally and by computer simulation to c
onfirm the intermediacy of coordination complexes of silver ion and th
e role of carboxylic acid as the reaction product responsible for posi
tive feedback in the development reaction. Our inferences are consiste
nt with the Klosterboer-Rutledge model of development, but also imply
that features of the recently proposed Usanov model are relevant as we
ll.