BELIEFS OF LARYNGECTOMEES ABOUT THE CAUSES OF THEIR CANCER AND ITS RELATIONSHIP WITH PSYCHOSOCIAL ADJUSTMENT AND PREOPERATIVE AND POSTOPERATIVE TOBACCO AND ALCOHOL-CONSUMPTION
H. Demaddalena et H. Pfrang, BELIEFS OF LARYNGECTOMEES ABOUT THE CAUSES OF THEIR CANCER AND ITS RELATIONSHIP WITH PSYCHOSOCIAL ADJUSTMENT AND PREOPERATIVE AND POSTOPERATIVE TOBACCO AND ALCOHOL-CONSUMPTION, HNO. Hals-, Nasen-, Ohrenarzte, 41(4), 1993, pp. 198-205
One or two days before operation 62 male patients with laryngeal or ph
aryngeal malignancies were questioned about their subjective beliefs c
oncerning the causes of their cancer. Additionally they were asked abo
ut their current and past tobacco and alcohol consumption. Six months
after the operation 51 of the 62 patients were interviewed about their
psychosocial adjustment and their postoperative tobacco and alcohol c
onsumption. Before the operation most of the patients (81%) reported t
hat they already had been thinking about the possible causes of their
malignant disease. Four out of five patients were smokers and consumed
alcohol daily, at least until disease onset. According to psychiatric
criteria more than 50% of the daily alcohol consumers were diagnosed
as alcoholics. As was expected, ''smoking'' was rated as the most impo
rtant causal factor in tumor etiology. Furthermore, ''air pollution'',
''unhealthy working conditions'' and ''fate'' were rated as important
pathogenic factors of the individual cancer. Surprisingly ''alcohol''
was only rated as an important causal factor by a few patients. The c
ausal factor ''smoking'' was correlated neither with actual pre- and p
ostoperative smoking behavior, nor with postoperative psychosocial adj
ustment.'' Alcohol'' was positively associated with a postoperative re
duction of alcohol consumption, on the one hand, and with increased po
stoperative psychological distress, on the other. Significant positive
relationships were also found between ''fate'' and postoperative psyc
hological distress and rejection of altered voice (e.g. laryngectomy).
In conclusion, medical information about the possible causes of cance
r should try to focus the attention of the patients on current and fut
ure stress factors and not on past risk behavior (e.g. alcohol and tob
acco consumption), which cannot be altered retrospectively. In order t
o avoid passivity and negative emotional adjustment, the physican shou
ld not reinforce the patients' self-reproach but support their active
coping efforts.