Adoption studies have led to the suggestion that there may be two dist
inct subgroups of alcoholics with differing genetic contributions. Amo
ng 249 male alcoholics we used discriminant analysis to relate the fea
tures of type 1 and type 2 alcoholism to the presence or absence of a
family history of alcoholism in male paternal relatives. We found that
guilt and binging, features usually attributed to type 1 (milieu-limi
ted) alcoholism, were in fact more prevalent in the family history pos
itive group. An additional cohort analysis found cohort-related variat
ions in type 1/type 2 characteristics. The possible implications of th
ese findings are discussed.