Jr. Roberts et al., ADVANTAGE OF HIGH-SURFACE-AREA CHARCOAL FOR GASTROINTESTINAL DECONTAMINATION IN A HUMAN ACETAMINOPHEN INGESTION MODEL, Academic emergency medicine, 4(3), 1997, pp. 167-174
Objective: To compare the abilities of low-surface-area (LSA) vs 2 typ
es of high-surface-area (HSA) activated charcoal given orally to adsor
b acetaminophen in the gastrointestinal (GI) tract, as demonstrated by
the impact of these agents on the serum levels and area under the cur
ve (AUC) in a simulated human overdose model. Methods: The main arm of
the study was a prospective double-blind crossover trial in which 6 v
olunteers, serving as their own controls, ingested acetaminophen (50 m
g/kg), followed randomly in 10 minutes by either powdered LSA charcoal
(950 m(2)/g) or powdered HSA charcoal (2,000 m(2)/g) in a charcoal:dr
ug ratio of 8:1. In a second arm of the study, 3 subjects additionally
ingested an equal dose of a granular preparation of the HSA charcoal.
Serial serum acetaminophen levels were analyzed at various intervals
(30, 60, 90, 120, 180, 240, and 300 minutes postingestion), and a 5-ho
ur AUC was calculated. The subjects also rated the charcoal preparatio
ns for palatability. Results: Serum acetaminophen levels were lower at
all measured times in the groups receiving both forms of the HSA char
coal vs the LSA product. With the powdered HSA charcoal, comparison se
rum levels were significantly lower at 120 minutes postingestion and a
ll times thereafter (p < 0.05), reaching high significance at 4 and 5
hours (p < 0.001). The subjects receiving the granular HSA charcoal al
so had consistently lower serum acetaminophen levels than did those re
ceiving the LSA product, and the difference in mean serum levels was s
ignificant at the 4- and 5-hour sample (p = 0.012). Compared with the
LSA charcoal; at the 4-hour postingestion sample, serum acetaminophen
levels were reduced by 44% to 85% by the powdered HSA charcoal. The to
tal AUC for the 5-hour study period was also significantly reduced by
the powdered HSA product (p = 0.005) and the granular HSA product (p =
0.043). All the subjects rated the powdered HSA charcoal to be more p
alatable and easier to drink than the powdered LSA charcoal. Conclusio
n: The surface area of oral activated charcoal is a major determining
factor in its ability to limit acetaminophen absorption and to fulfill
its adsorptive role in GI decontamination. In a human acetaminophen o
verdose model, 2 types of HSA charcoal, when compared with equal doses
of LSA charcoal, significantly reduced serum levels and total acetami
nophen absorption as measured by the AUC.