Sj. London et al., FATTY-ACID COMPOSITION OF THE SUBCUTANEOUS ADIPOSE-TISSUE AND RISK OFPROLIFERATIVE BENIGN BREAST DISEASE AND BREAST-CANCER, Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 85(10), 1993, pp. 785-793
Background. Studies in animals and geographic correlations across popu
lations suggest that fatty acid intake may have a positive relationshi
p with breast cancer risk, but analytic epidemiologic studies of fat i
ntake have been less supportive. Adipose tissue analysis provides a mo
re objective assessment of intakes of fatty acids that are not endogen
ously synthesized than do the questionnaire survey methods used in man
y epidemiologic studies. Purpose: This case-control study of postmenop
ausal women was designed to examine the relationship between fatty aci
d composition of subcutaneous adipose tissue and risk of breast cancer
and proliferative benign breast disease. In addition, we examined spe
cific hypotheses that breast cancer risk is negatively associated with
long-chain N-3 fatty acid intake, positively associated with trans fa
tty acid intake, and positively associated with increased intake of po
lyunsaturated fat together with low intake of antioxidants. Methods: A
spirates of subcutaneous fat from the buttocks were obtained from 380
women with newly diagnosed stage I or II breast cancer and 176 with pr
oliferative benign breast disease. A total of 397 women who were evalu
ated for breast abnormalities at the same institutions but did not req
uire breast biopsy or whose biopsy revealed nonproliferative benign br
east disease served as the control group. We examined associations bet
ween saturated, monounsaturated, polyunsaturated, trans, or long-chain
N-3 fatty acids and breast cancer, atypical hyperplasia, or prolifera
tive benign breast disease without atypia. Results: We observed no con
sistent patterns of association between breast cancer risk and any of
the categories of fatty acids or the individual constituent fatty acid
s in the adipose tissue. Saturated fatty acids were inversely associat
ed with risk of proliferative benign breast disease without atypia but
not with atypical hyperplasia or breast cancer. This association was
not observed, however, when total fat intake was taken into account. W
omen with high levels of polyunsaturated fatty acids in adipose tissue
and low serum or dietary levels of antioxidants were not observed to
be at higher risk of breast cancer. Conclusions: Using an objective me
asure of intake, we observed no major associations between polyunsatur
ated fatty acids, including long-chain N-3 fatty acids and trans fatty
acids, and risk of breast cancer or proliferative benign breast disea
se. Implications: These data do not support the hypothesis that intake
of specific fatty acids, particularly polyunsaturated and trans fatty
acids, is an important risk factor for malignant or benign breast dis
ease.