Nucleic acid hybridization has been used to detect viral nucleic acid
in water. This type of assay, in contrast with tissue culture assays,
may not distinguish between viable and non-viable viruses. We evaluate
d, by comparison with tissue culture infectivity assay (plaque forming
method), the ability of the gene probe assay to detect viable poliovi
rus 1 (LSc) in well water, autoclaved well water, filter-sterilized we
ll water and autoclaved phosphate buffered saline kept at 37 and 15-de
grees-C for 75 days, and in dechlorinated tap water held at room tempe
rature. A gradual decline in numbers of poliovirus was observed in all
of the samples by cell culture assay. With the exception of autoclave
d well water and phosphate buffer, a parallel decline in virus detecta
ble by gene probe occurred in all other water samples. These results s
uggest that detection of poliovirus 1, by gene probe, is influenced by
the presence of microorganisms or their products and to a lesser exte
nt by temperature. This suggests that in some natural waters, the dete
ction of poliovirus 1, by gene probe, may be expected to correlate to
detection by tissue culture.