Vi. Kalikmanov et Meh. Vandongen, SELF-CONSISTENT CLUSTER APPROACH TO THE HOMOGENEOUS KINETIC NUCLEATION THEORY, Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics, 47(5), 1993, pp. 3532-3539
An alternative, self-consistent formulation of the homogeneous nucleat
ion theory has been proposed. This approach differs from the classical
Becker-Doring-Zeldovich theory in two respects: (i) evaporation rates
are evaluated by referring to the stable equilibrium of a saturated v
apor rather than to the constrained metastable equilibrium of a supers
aturated vapor; and (ii) for the reference stable equilibrium state th
e Fisher theory of condensation is used in order to obtain a self-cons
istent definition of the free-energy barrier for 1-cluster formation,
where 1 is the number of molecules in the cluster. A comparison of the
expressions for the nucleation rate and critical cluster size with th
e corresponding classical expressions has been made for the different
parts of the phase diagram (temperature-supersaturation) and the domai
n where both theories are close has been found. Predictions of the pre
sent theory have been compared with the experimental results on nuclea
tion of n-nonane for the three sets of experiments (diffusion cloud ch
amber, fast-expansion cloud chamber, and two-piston cloud chamber). It
has been shown that the present theory has a much better agreement wi
th experimental results for n-nonane than the classical theory.