D. Puschel, THE THEORY OF THE GLIDING SPECTRUM OF PSYCHIC DISTURBANCES - THE CASUISTIC OF A SCHIZOPHRENICALLY STRUCTURED PERSONALITY, Dynamische Psychiatrie, 26(1-4), 1993, pp. 201-215
The author takes up an early statement by Freud, who said about a schi
zophrenic patient, that his healing process started by re-establishing
the Oedipus-Complex - a first hint at the possibility of treating psy
chosis through psychotherapy. Freud thus regarded psychotic symptoms a
s shifting and so began free himself from the narrowing categories of
classical psychiatry. Based on the concept of the shift of symptoms Gu
nter Ammons Dynamic Psychiatry regards the genesis, structure and dyna
mics of neurosis, borderline-syndrome, psychosomatic diseases, drugadd
iction, destructive sexuality and psychosis as placed on a gliding spe
ctrum. Provided the patient is treated adequately there will be a freq
uent change of symptoms and a development towards more health, which r
equires a new diagnosis. In german-speaking countries psychiatrists ha
ve been trying for about hundred years to find new ways in diagnosing,
but in spite of more and more detailed systematics they haven't been
successful yet. Today we know that it is necessary for the treatment o
f psychotic patient to offer a therapeutic field like the Dynamic Psyc
hiatric Hospital Menterschwaige in Munich consisting of a network of s
ingle-, group- and milieutherapy as well as music-, dance-, theatre-,
painting- and horseriding-therapy (Ammon, Burbiel 1992; Schmidts 1990)
. The importance of this groupdynamic and integrative therapeutic conc
ept can be illustrated by the therapy of a 47 year old patient, who ha
d lived isolated with the diagnosis >>paranoid-halluzinatory psychosis
<<. When she came to us she reported to have been telepathically extor
ted, threatened and subdued for years by a strange power. She thought
all her actions were examined, and psychosomatic symptoms occurred, es
pecially when she tried to find a job. Diagnostic tests show formal re
asoning problems and blocades, paranoic fantasies, reduced language co
mpetence, strong ambivalence, autistic regression, disturbances of att
ention and concentration and most of all anxiety. As for her family dy
namics is concerned, there is significantly high symbiotic contact wit
h her mother she shared the sleeping-room with, while her father was e
xiled into the kitchen. She was the substitute for her mother's partne
r, but at the same time felt rivalry and jealousy towards her elder an
d more successful sister - being the scapegoat our patient thus held t
he family together. At the age of 14 she suffered from erythrophobia a
nd regression, later from psychosomatic reactions and skincancer, then
she was labeled with the diagnosis >>psychiatric desintegration<< and
at least she tried to get help from no less than 37 different medical
and psychological institutions - both ambulant and in-patient. The pr
ognoses were mostly bad, but the patient didnt give up. At the beginni
ng of the analytic treatment in our hospital, the importance of the sy
mbiosis-conflict that's behind the symptoms becomes evident - it's nev
er been possible for the patient to get out of the symbiosis with her
mother without feeling guilty - this dynamic became apparent in the si
ngletherapy situation, when she showed a strong wish melting into one
another with the therapist. While the female therapist tried to streng
then all the contructive parts of the patient, the patient more and mo
re tested her, if she could place confidence in the therapist, control
led her and tried to make her part of her halluzinations. During this
phase the nonverbal therapies became important, especially in the danc
ing therapy she could experience her still repressed creative potentia
l; the pictures made in the drawingtherapy became relevant as non-verb
al expressions, the growing transference-relation showed strong symbio
tic jealousy towards other patients in order to defend her fear of bei
ng left alone. The counter-transference of the therapist helped to und
erstand the unconscious dynamic of the patient. Despite of different m
echanisms of defense (idealization, projection etc.) the patient could
take first steps towards an own identity, she could free herself from
deficient ego-demarcation and the hallucination of being influenced f
rom outside; she had dreams instead, was elected project-leader in the
milieutherapy, moved more freely in the dancing-therapy and played a
part in the theatre-therapy that represented her own groupdynamic. The
dreams discuessed in the single-therapy gave decisive clues and helpe
d her to get away from the destructive dynamics of the past. Eroticism
, sexuality and oedipal problems finally became in the therapeutic pro
cess, the patient tried a cautions loverelation with another patient a
nd her menstruation came back again after six years break. She took fi
rst steps in building up a career in the social field and increasingly
dealt with the world outside. She prepared herself for an ambulant th
erapy with a male psychotherapist and showed none of her previous symp
toms any more. Apart from occasional sleeping pills the patient has ne
ver used any psychopharmacological medication. Even now, more than one
year after leaving the hospital the patient feels good, she has no sy
mptoms, she has moved away from her parents and works in a project for
the integration of foreign children. She herself has described her wa
y as from >>telepathy to empathy<<.