Objective: To assess the status of laparoscopic general surgery in Can
ada and the training experience and educational needs of Canadian surg
eons, particularly with laparoscopic cholecystectomy (LC). Design: All
of Canada's practising general surgeons were surveyed by mail approxi
mately 15 months after the general availability of laparoscopic video
equipment. Questionnaires completed by 736 surgeons form the basis of
the analysis.Setting. The respondent profile produced a good sample di
stribution to assess differences related to age, experience, location
and type of practice; 30% practised in communities of 50 000 or less;
38% in hospitals with 250 or fewer beds and 57% in community hospitals
. Results: Eighty-four percent had already learned LC, and 51% of them
had performed more than 25 LCs. The number performed correlated direc
tly with the number of cholecystectomies usually performed yearly befo
re laparoscopy. Age and lack of relevance to practice were reasons for
not learning. Ninety-one percent took formal training courses, usuall
y university sponsored and in Canada. Complications were experienced b
y 44% of respondents. Bile leak (26%), hemorrhage (15%) and bile-duct
injury (9%) were the most common and increased as the number of cholec
ystectomies usually performed prior to LC increased. Age, sex, type an
d location of hospital and size of city were not significant factors.
The data show a consistent (p < 0.001) increase in the proportion of s
urgeons who encountered a complication as the number of LCs performed
increased. Conclusions: LC has been introduced in Canada in an unpredi
cted, rapid and seemingly orderly and responsible fashion in all areas
, types and sizes of communities. It has been equally well applied by
surgeons of all ages and size of practice whether practising in the sm
aller community or in the university centre. The dogma of complication
s releated to a ''learning curve'' is not supported by the author's da
ta, and experience with complications is not restricted to the occasio
nal biliary surgeon. Continued vigilance is necessary.