Bl. Zhang et al., SIMULTANEOUS DETERMINATION OF PRIMARY AND SECONDARY THERMODYNAMIC ISOTOPE EFFECTS IN TAUTOMERIC EQUILIBRIA, Journal of physical organic chemistry, 6(6), 1993, pp. 367-373
NMR determination of site-specific hydrogen isotope ratios at natural
deuterium abundance (SNIF-NMR) provides the basis for simultaneous acc
ess to primary and secondary thermodynamic fractionation factors in ex
change reactions and avoids the need for selective isotope labelling o
f the reagents. The method was applied to the measurement of fractiona
tion parameters involving OH, CH2, CH3 and =CH groups in keto-enol tau
tomeric equilibria. The fractionation factors relating the =CH and OH
sites of the enol species are simply derived from H-2 NMR spectra wher
eas the determination of isotope parameters which relate keto and enol
positions exploits a combination of H-2 and H-1 NMR experiments. Sinc
e only monolabelled isotopomers have to be considered at natural abund
ance, the method also offers the advantage of avoiding the occurrence
of complex equilibria associated with multi-labelled species possibly
introduced by deuterium enrichment. The primary equilibrium isotope ef
fects illustrate a preference of deuterium for the methylene fragment
of the keto form with respect to the ethylenic position of the enol ta
utomer. Since the enol species is itself engaged in a fast tautomeric
equilibrium associated with a symmetric or unsymmetric double minimum
potential, the thermodynamic parameters are averaged over the exchangi
ng partners. It is shown that the average thermodynamic fractionation
factor relating the OH and =CH hydrogens of the enol are significantly
influenced by the nature of the substituents at both carbonyl positio
ns of the beta-diketones. Moreover, methyl and chlorine substitution i
ncreases by a factor of about 1.1 the thermodynamic isotopic fractiona
tion factor relating the -COCHCO- position of the keto form to the hyd
roxyl position of the enol.