Analysis of historical narratives produced in a German community shows
them to be metaphors for a range of issues touching on the general th
eme of local autonomy. The tendency of home town historians to invoke
a medieval golden age is reminiscent of nationalist historiographic co
nventions, but variations in social context raise questions about the
precise nature of the relationship between these two traditions. When
viewed from different perspectives, home town history may appear to re
present either accommodation or resistance to dominant ideologies; but
it is best viewed as a variety of essentialist rhetoric, which serves
to establish distinct yet communicable identities for various local g
roups.