Many observers perceive depth when a configuration of nonconcentric ci
rcles is rotated on a disc. While it has been suggested by a number of
investigators that motion parallax has a role in generating this phen
omenon, the supporting data are equivocal. The current study proposed
that the ambiguity regarding the role of motion parallax may have aris
en because there are contradictions between relative size cues and mot
ion parallax cues in the configuration of rotating circles. However, w
ith 17 undergraduate observers, apparent depth was no more reliably re
ported with consistent cues of motion parallax and relative size than
when these cues were contradictory.