I. Petrov et al., AVERAGE ENERGY DEPOSITED PER ATOM - A UNIVERSAL PARAMETER FOR DESCRIBING ION-ASSISTED FILM GROWTH, Applied physics letters, 63(1), 1993, pp. 36-38
The average energy deposited per atom, [E(d)] = E(i)(J(i)/J(Me)), wher
e E(i) is the ion energy and J(i)/J(Me) is the ratio of the accelerate
d-ion to deposited-thermal-particle fluxes incident at the growing fil
m, has been shown to be one of a set of parameters useful for describi
ng the effects of low-energy ion irradiation on film microstructure du
ring ion-assisted deposition. Recently, however, [E(d)] has often been
treated as if it were a fundamental, or universal, parameter. We have
carried out experiments in which E(i) (20-100 eV) and J(i)/J(Me) (1-1
0) were varied independently during the deposition, at constant temper
ature, of polycrystalline Ti0.5Al0.5N films onto amorphous SiO2 substr
ates by ultrahigh vacuum reactive magnetron sputtering in pure nitroge
n. Ion-irradiation-induced changes in film microstructure, texture, ph
ase composition, and nitrogen-to-metal ratio were found to follow dist
inctly different mechanistic pathways depending upon whether E(i) or J
(i)/J(Me) was varied, resulting in quite different properties for the
same value of [E(d)]. Thus, [E(d)] is clearly not a universal paramete
r.