Increased meniscal MR signal attributable to meniscal degeneration is
a common finding. The role of different MR sequences in the analysis o
f the extent and distribution of meniscal degeneration in middle-aged
and elderly patients has not been thoroughly evaluated. We retrospecti
vely studied the role of different MR sequences in 175 anatomic menisc
al sections originating from 20 freshly frozen knees from 10 cadavers
using MR-anatomic correlation. T1-weighted and proton-density spin-ech
o images as well as postprocessed meniscal windows based on T1-weighte
d spin-echo images proved to be the most reliable in this diagnosis (5
3.7%, 54.9%, and 53.1% correctly diagnosed meniscal sections, respecti
vely). T2-weighted spin-echo images and gradient-echo images proved to
be less reliable (37.1% and 40.0% correctly diagnosed meniscal sectio
ns). While the T2-weighted spin-echo images commonly underestimated th
e extent of meniscal degeneration, gradient-echo images commonly overe
stimated the extent of such changes. These last two types of sequences
should not be used alone in the description of meniscal degeneration.