The purpose of this study was to determine the relationship between th
e deterioration and the later failure of a very large number of amalga
ms and anterior resin composites examined over periods of up to 16 yea
rs. Assessments were made of the deterioration of various clinical fac
tors or characteristics of the restorative materials that were thought
to predict later failures. True failures, which were directly related
to the restorative materials, accounted for 7.5% of the amalgam and 3
0.4% of the composite restorations. For the amalgams, there was a sign
ificant association found between the failures and surface tarnishing.
Marginal fracture and marginal staining were not associated significa
ntly with any of the three different failure modes. For the composites
there were significant associations found between the failures and su
rface roughness, marginal fracture, and color mismatch. Surface staini
ng and marginal staining were not associated significantly with any of
the three different failure modes. Many restorations assessed as bein
g unsatisfactory continued to function for a further 2.5 to 3.5 years
on average before being replaced, often for unrelated reasons. There i
s a need to define unsatisfactory restorations more clearly in terms o
f actual adverse effects on dental health, rather than merely in terms
of restoration deterioration.