Ar. Crosland et al., AN INTERLABORATORY COMPARISON OF A STANDARDIZED EDTA EXTRACTION PROCEDURE FOR THE ANALYSIS OF AVAILABLE TRACE-ELEMENTS IN 2 QUALITY-CONTROLSOILS, International journal of environmental analytical chemistry, 51(1-4), 1993, pp. 153-160
A standardised EDTA extraction procedure was tested collaboratively by
six laboratories using two in-house reference soils identified as soi
l A and soil B. The extracts were analysed for Zn. Cu, Pb and Mn by In
ductively Coupled Plasma Spectrometry. Concentrations of extractable e
lements in soil A were generally much lower than those found in soil B
. All laboratories produced some extreme outlying results, most of the
se were produced in soil B. Results for Mn were the most variable, wit
h a range of 63.4-100.3 mug g-1 in soil A and 226.4-415.3 mug g-1 in s
oil B. In both soils, one laboratory reported high values for Zn and M
n and, one laboratory, for soil B, produced values for all four elemen
ts which were consistently low. If outlying results are ignored, the r
esults from most laboratories were in reasonable agreement for all ele
ments except Mn.