De. Wolfe et C. Hom, USE OF MELODIES AS STRUCTURAL PROMPTS FOR LEARNING AND RETENTION OF SEQUENTIAL VERBAL INFORMATION BY PRESCHOOL STUDENTS, The Journal of music therapy, 30(2), 1993, pp. 100-118
The present investigation examined the effects of particular combinati
ons of spoken and sung stimulus input using both familiar and unfamili
ar melodies on immediate recall and retention of sequential verbal mat
erial. Twenty-one 5-year-old students enrolled in a Head Start program
initially participated in learning six individually selected telephon
e numbers, four of which were incorporated within melodic phrases, two
of which were spoken. Ten of these students completed the entire trai
ning. Using a within-subjects, repeated-measures design in which the t
raining phases were counterbalanced across subjects, students progress
ed through each of the following training phases (TP): TPI (a) telepho
ne number with familiar melody, (b) telephone number with speech; TPII
(a) telephone number with unfamiliar melody, (b) telephone number wit
h speech and contingent music; TPIII (a) telephone number with familia
r melody and contingent music, (b) telephone number with unfamiliar me
lody and contingent music. A reverse chaining procedure was used to te
ach each number. Both telephone numbers within each training phase had
to be repeated three times in a row for three consecutive sessions be
fore the student was ready to progress to the next training phase. Dur
ing the contingent music conditions, the student received the continge
ncy (was allowed to select and play one of the following: maraca, jing
le stick, drum, omnichord) when he or she reached acquisition with any
of the digits being worked on that particular session. The total numb
er of trials it took for each student to learn each of the six telepho
ne numbers was recorded along with each student's instrument selection
. Post-rehearsal checks and post-test scores were also recorded. Stati
stical analyses revealed that the mean number of trials it took studen
ts to learn telephone numbers couched within familiar melodies was sig
nificantly less than for the unfamiliar and spoken conditions. However
, there was no significant difference in trials to criterion among the
contingent and noncontingent conditions. Results also showed nonsigni
ficant differences in the number of digits remembered during post-rehe
arsal checks (immediate recall) and the posttest (retention) across th
e experimental phases. Further statistical analyses are given with imp
lications for music therapy/education discussed.