Wh. Traub et B. Leonhard, ANTIBIOTIC SUSCEPTIBILITY OF ALPHAHEMOLYTIC AND NONHEMOLYTIC STREPTOCOCCI FROM PATIENTS AND HEALTHY-ADULTS TO 24 ANTIMICROBIAL DRUGS, Chemotherapy, 43(2), 1997, pp. 123-131
A total of 278 alpha- and nonhemolytic streptococcal isolates (patient
s, n = 116; healthy adults, n = 162) were examined for susceptibility
to 23 and 24 antimicrobial drugs with the Bauer-Kirby agar disk diffus
ion and the agar dilution method, respectively. Wilkins-Chalgren mediu
m compared favorably with sheep blood Mueller-Hinton agar, the referen
ce medium, for 58 representative streptococcal isolates. In terms of m
inimal inhibitory concentrations (MICs), all 278 isolates were suscept
ible to teicoplanin and vancomycin. None of the isolates revealed high
-level gentamicin resistance. All isolates were resistant to fusidic a
cid. Twelve Streptococcus mitis isolates, all from patients, were resi
stant to penicillin G and variably to other antibiotics. Oxacillin dis
ks failed to predict penicillin G susceptibility. In general, patient
isolates were more frequently resistant to beta-lactam antibiotics and
fluoroquinolones; conversely, isolates from healthy carriers were sli
ghtly more resistant to macrolide antibiotics. Specifically, susceptib
ility rates were: penicillin G 79.1%, oxacillin 87.8%, ampicillin 66.9
%, piperacillin 98.2%, cefoxitin 76.6%, cefuroxime 96.8%, cefotaxime 9
8.6%, ceftriaxone 98.6%, cefepime 98.6%, imipenem 98.2%, ciprofloxacin
59.7%, ofloxacin 89.2%, doxycycline 65.8%, tetracycline 56.8%, clinda
mycin 87.8%, erythromycin 59%, clarithromycin 74.9%, chloramphenicol 9
8.9%, cotrimoxazole 97.9%, rifampin 97.5%, and fosfomycin 2.2%. On the
basis of numerous minor discrepancies between disk diffusion and agar
dilution test results for certain antibiotics, it is proposed that th
e current NCCLS inhibition zone (diameter, mm) criteria indicative of
intermediate susceptibility of alpha- and nonhemolytic streptococci be
changed for the following antimicrobial drugs: ampicillin = I = 22-27
mm; ciprofloxacin = I = 16-18 mm; clindamycin = I = 15-18 mm; doxycyc
line = I = 17-19 mm; tetracycline = I = 17-19 mm; erythromycin = I = 1
4-19 mm, and cotrimoxazole = I = 11-13 mm. It is recommended to exclud
e both cefoxitin and doxycycline (substitute = tetracycline) disks fro
m test batteries for non-group A, B beta-hemolytic and alpha-/nonhemol
ytic streptococcal isolates.