The significance of palpable non-metastatic (false-positive) lymph nod
es in the neck of patients with head and neck cancer is not quite clea
r. These nodes may be the result of inflammation, which usually accomp
anies the primary tumor, or they may reflect an immunological response
of the patient to the tumor. The present study was undertaken to eluc
idate this problem by comparing the survival rate of patients with fal
se-positive necks to the rates of patients with true-negative, false-n
egative, or true-positive necks. The records of 138 patients with prim
ary squamous cell carcinoma of the oral cavity who were treated surgic
ally between 1980 and 1987 at the University of Toronto were reviewed.
There were 53 patients with true-negative necks, 18 with false-negati
ve necks, 35 false-positive necks, and the remaining 32 patients had t
rue-positive necks. T-stage was the single variable with a significant
impact on survival. Nodal status did not influence survival in patien
ts with large primary tumors. In patients with TI or T2 cancers, occul
t nodes did not, but palpable nodes did have a detrimental impact on s
urvival. The presence of false-positive nodes did not have a beneficia
l effect on survival in this study. Possible explanations for this obs
ervation are discussed.