COMPARISON OF SURVIVAL CURVES OF GASTRIC-CANCER PATIENTS AFTER SURGERY ACCORDING TO THE UICC STAGE CLASSIFICATION AND THE GENERAL RULES FORGASTRIC-CANCER STUDY BY THE JAPANESE-RESEARCH-SOCIETY-FOR-GASTRIC-CANCER
Y. Nio et al., COMPARISON OF SURVIVAL CURVES OF GASTRIC-CANCER PATIENTS AFTER SURGERY ACCORDING TO THE UICC STAGE CLASSIFICATION AND THE GENERAL RULES FORGASTRIC-CANCER STUDY BY THE JAPANESE-RESEARCH-SOCIETY-FOR-GASTRIC-CANCER, Annals of surgery, 218(1), 1993, pp. 47-53
Objective This study compared the UICC classification with the General
Rules for Gastric Cancer Study (GRGCS) of the Japanese Research Socie
ty by analyzing recent results of gastric cancer surgery in Japan. Sum
mary Background Data The present UICC stage classification for gastric
cancer was published in 1987 and the Japanese GRGCS were published in
1985. Both are based on the results of surveys conducted in the early
1970s. Methods The survival curves of 926 patients, who underwent gas
tric cancer surgery between 1982 and 1985 at Kyoto University Hospital
and its 31 associated hospitals, were analyzed according to the UICC
classification and the GRGCS using SAS computer software. Results Ther
e was no difference in survival rate between UICC stages IA and IB. GR
GCS stage III was found to include UICC stages II, IIIA, and IIIB, and
GRGCS stage IV included UICC stages IIIA, IIIB, and IV, with signific
antly different survival rates. In contrast, each UICC stage included
different GRGCS stages with no significant differences in survival rat
es. The survival rate of stage IV patients of both classifications who
underwent gastrectomy was significantly higher than that of stage IV
patients receiving bypass or exploratory surgeries. Conclusions The UI
CC classification is better than the GRGCS for classifying gastric can
cer in Japan. However, UICC stage I does not need to be subdivided int
o stages IA and IB, and stage IV should be further subdivided into sta
ges IVA and IVB according to the surgery performed: IVA, gastrectomy,
and IVB, bypass or exploratory surgery.