Redundant protection, tariffs that exceed the domestic import-price di
fferential, is an important feature of nineteenth century U.S. tariff
history and remains a common practice in many developing countries. Th
is paper develops political-economy models of the tariff setting proce
ss when the world price of the importable product is stochastic. The o
ptimal endogenous tariff may involve redundant protection even if agen
ts are risk neutral. These political-economy models also permit us to
assess the comparative static effects of changes in the mean-preservin
g spread of the world price under differing assumptions about the poli
tical process.