Hg. Demars et al., COMPARISON OF GENERALIZED TRANSPORT AND MONTE-CARLO MODELS OF THE ESCAPE OF A MINOR SPECIES, Journal of atmospheric and terrestrial physics, 55(11-12), 1993, pp. 1583-1594
In a wide variety of space physics problems (e.g. polar wind, solar wi
nd), outflowing species pass through two different regions: (1) a coll
ision-dominated region, in which hydrodynamic transport equations can
be applied, and (2) a collisionless region. where kinetic models are a
pplicable. These two regions are separated by a transition layer where
more rigorous mathematical approaches should be used. One such approa
ch is the Monte-Carlo method. The Monte-Carlo technique uses pseudo-ra
ndom numbers to simulate the diffusion of a given species under the in
fluence of gravitational and electromagnetic forces and interparticle
collisions. A second possible approach is to use generalized transport
equations. The 16-moment set of transport equations, considered here,
is obtained by taking moments of Boltzmann's equation, assuming that
the particle distribution function is an expansion about a bi-Maxwelli
an with correction terms proportional to the stress and the parallel a
nd perpendicular beat flows. The purpose of this study is not to provi
de a new or better description of a particular flow in space. It is, r
ather, to compare the Monte-Carlo and 16-moment generalized transport
approaches for conditions corresponding to the transition from collisi
on-dominated to collisionless flow and to draw conclusions about these
two methods based on the results of the comparison. The 16-moment and
Monte-Carlo approaches are compared for the case of a minor species d
iffusing through a static background. First, the problem is cast in a
form which makes the description independent of the way in which the b
ackground density varies with distance. For this transformed problem,
the 16-moment and Monte-Carlo models show close agreement. Then, the t
ransformed problem is 'mapped' to a particular case that approximates
conditions existing in the Earth's upper atmosphere. The general agree
ment between the Monte-Carlo and 16-moment model solutions for the map
ped problem is evidence that the 16-moment formalism is capable of suc
cessfully describing transitions from collision-dominated to collision
less flow.