Ad. Vinokur et M. Vanryn, SOCIAL SUPPORT AND UNDERMINING IN CLOSE RELATIONSHIPS - THEIR INDEPENDENT EFFECTS ON THE MENTAL-HEALTH OF UNEMPLOYED PERSONS, Journal of personality and social psychology, 65(2), 1993, pp. 350-359
Structural equation analyses were used to examine the impact of social
support vs. social undermining (conflict) on mental health in longitu
dinal data from 1,087 recently unemployed respondents. The results dem
onstrated that social support and social undermining were not the oppo
site poles of the same factor, each having some impact independent of
the other. Social undermining had statistically significant and strong
adverse impact at each concurrent level of mental health. It also pre
dicted improvement (but not a high level) in mental health in subseque
nt time waves. In contrast, social support had a significant beneficia
l impact on mental health only at Time 1. Compared with the volatile a
nd extreme effects of social undermining, those of social support appe
ar weaker but more stable. These findings are consistent with literatu
re on the impact of life events (S. E. Taylor, 1991) and on marital in
teractions and satisfaction (J. M. Gottman & L. J. Krokoff, 1989).