An urge to breathe is perceived during breath hold and hypercapnia (te
rmed 'air hunger') and during heavy exercise (often termed 'shortness
of breath'). To better understand the neural mechanisms responsible fo
r these sensations we studied five patients (8-17 years old) with cong
enital central hypoventilation syndrome (CCHS) who lack ventilatory re
sponse to CO2. CCHS patients reported no respiratory discomfort during
CO2 inhalation or during maximal breath hold which was of much longer
duration than age-matched controls. However, all 3 CCHS patients who
exercised heavily reported some sensations akin to shortness of breath
(they increased breathing nearly as much as controls). Our results ar
e consistent with two possibilities. First, the air hunger of hypercap
nia and breath hold is caused by projection to the forebrain of respir
atory chemoreceptor afferents which bypass the respiratory centers, wh
ile exercise shortness of breath is caused by direct projections of li
mb afferents or locomotory center activity. Second, air hunger and sho
rtness of breath share the same origin - projection of increased brain
stem respiratory center motor activity (corollary discharge) to the f
orebrain.