C. Dean et al., COMPARISON OF COMMUNITY-BASED SERVICE WITH HOSPITAL-BASED SERVICE FORPEOPLE WITH ACUTE, SEVERE PSYCHIATRIC-ILLNESS, BMJ. British medical journal, 307(6902), 1993, pp. 473-476
Objective-To compare the burden on relatives and outcome of people tre
ated for severe acute psychiatric illness by a community service and a
traditional hospital based service. Design-Follow up of patients aged
16-65 who required admission to hospital or home treatment for psychi
atric illness during january 1990 to February 1991. Setting-Two Birmin
gham electoral wards, Sparkbrook and Small Heath; Sparkbrook has a com
munity based service and Small Heath a traditional hospital based serv
ice. Subjects-69 patients from Sparkbrook and 55 from Small Heath. Mai
n outcome measures-Scores on present state examination, social behavio
ur assessment schedule, and general health questionnaire. Results-24 (
35%) of Sparkbrook patients received some treatment in hospital during
the initial episodes. Relatives of Sparkbrook patients were less dist
ressed by their burden at the initial assessment than relatives of Sma
ll Heath patients (mean score 0.11 v 0.29, p<0.01). Relatives were als
o more satisfied with the support they received and the treatment rece
ived by patients. More patients from Sparkbrook than Small Heath were
in contact with a psychiatrist (81% (95% confidence interval 71% to 91
%) v 62% (44% to 68%)) and community nurse (56% (44% to 68%) v 14% (13
% to 24%)) one year after the initial episode. Sparkbrook patients spe
nt significantly fewer days in hospital during the initial episode (8
days v 59 days) and the first year (20.6 v 67.9 days). Conclusion-The
community based service is as effective as the hospital based service
and is preferred by relatives. It is more effective in keeping people
in long term contact with psychiatrists.