Mr. Trenerry et al., QUANTITATIVE MRI HIPPOCAMPAL VOLUMES - ASSOCIATION WITH ONSET AND DURATION OF EPILEPSY, AND FEBRILE CONVULSIONS IN TEMPORAL LOBECTOMY PATIENTS, Epilepsy research, 15(3), 1993, pp. 247-252
The relationships between preoperatively acquired MRI-based hippocampa
l volumes (HV), seizure disorder onset and duration, and early childho
od febrile convulsions were investigated retrospectively with data fro
m 72 left and 56 right temporal lobectomy patients. Patients with lesi
onal pathology and heterotopic abnormalities were excluded. Age at dev
elopment of spontaneous seizures unprovoked by an acute illness define
d age of seizure disorder onset. Age of onset was subtracted from age
at neurosurgery to determine duration. MRI variables included in this
study were the right and left HV divided by total intracranial volume
(RAHV, LAHV), and the right - left hippocampal difference (DHF). Parti
al correlations were used to better isolate relationships with onset o
f recurrent seizures corrected for age at surgery, and age at neurosur
gery corrected for age of recurrent seizure onset. Partial correlation
s between age at neurosurgery and volume were not significant in eithe
r group. LAHV (r = 0.42, P < 0.0003) and DHF (r = -0.49, P < 0.0001)(
were correlated with age of onset in the left lobectomy group. Correla
tions in the right lobectomy group were not significant. The presence
of a febrile convulsion was associated with smaller LAHV (F(1,70) = 10
.54, P < 0.002) and larger DHF (F(1,70) = 11.36, P < 0.002) in left te
mporal lobectomy patients. The presence of a febrile convulsion in the
right temporal group was associated with a slightly smaller DHF (F(1,
56) = 5.90, P < 0.02), and slightly smaller RAHV (F(1,56) = 4.49, P <
0.04). These data suggest that hippocampal atrophy remains stable over
the duration of temporal lobe onset seizure disorders, and is associa
ted with early onset of recurrent seizures in left temporal patients.
The difference across lobectomy groups in the magnitude of effect with
regard to presence of a febrile convulsion, and the lack of correlati
on between hippocampal atrophy and onset of recurrent seizures in the
right lobectomy group may be due to the interaction of developmental d
ifferences in brain morphology and timing of the insult that produces
hippocampal pathology.