N. Spruston et al., VOLTAGE-CLAMP AND SPACE-CLAMP ERRORS ASSOCIATED WITH THE MEASUREMENT OF ELECTROTONICALLY REMOTE SYNAPTIC EVENTS, Journal of neurophysiology, 70(2), 1993, pp. 781-802
1. The voltage- and space-clamp errors associated with the use of a so
matic electrode to measure current from dendritic synapses are evaluat
ed using both equivalent-cylinder and morphologically realistic models
of neuronal dendritic trees. 2. As a first step toward understanding
the properties of synaptic current distortion under voltage-clamp cond
itions, the attenuation of step and sinusoidal voltage changes are eva
luated in equivalent cylinder models. Demonstration of the frequency-d
ependent attenuation of voltage in the cable is then used as a framewo
rk for understanding the distortion of synaptic currents generated at
sites remote from the somatic recording electrode and measured in the
voltage-clamp recording configuration. 3. Increases in specific membra
ne resistivity (R(m)) are shown to reduce steady-state voltage attenua
tion, while producing only minimal reduction in attenuation of transie
nt voltage changes. Experimental manipulations that increase R(m) ther
efore improve the accuracy of estimates of reversal potential for elec
trotonically remote synapses, but do not significantly reduce the atte
nuation of peak current. In addition, increases in R(m) have the effec
t of slowing the kinetics of poorly clamped synaptic currents. 4. The
effects of the magnitude of the synaptic conductance and its kinetics
on the measured synaptic currents are also examined and discussed. The
error in estimating parameters from measured synaptic currents is gre
atest for synapses with fast kinetics and large conductances. 5. A mor
phologically realistic model of a CA3 pyramidal neuron is used to demo
nstrate the generality of the conclusions derived from equivalent cyli
nder models. The realistic model is also used to fit synaptic currents
generated by stimulation of mossy fiber (MF) and commissural/associat
ional (C/A) inputs to CA3 neurons and to estimate the amount of distor
tion of these measured currents.6. Anatomic data from the CA3 pyramida
l neuron model are used to construct a simplified two-cylinder CA3 mod
el. This model is used to estimate the electrotonic distances of MF sy
napses (which are located proximal to the soma) and perforant path (PP
) synapses (which are located at the distal ends of the apical dendrit
es) and the distortion of synaptic current parameters measured or thes
e synapses. 7. Results from the equivalent-cylinder models, the morpho
logical CA3 model, and the simplified CA3 model all indicate that the
amount of distortion of synaptic currents increases steeply as a funct
ion of distance from the soma. MF synapses close to the soma are likel
y to be subject only to small space-clamp errors, whereas MF synapses
farther from the soma are likely to be substantially attenuated. Synap
tic currents from more remote synapses such as C/A and PP inputs are s
hown to be enormously attenuated. 8. In conclusion, we show that despi
te experimental manipulations to eliminate somatic leak conductances a
nd increase R(m), synaptic currents generated in neuronal dendrites an
d measured at the soma can still be significantly attenuated and disto
rted. Estimates of synaptic conductances and kinetics from voltage-cla
mp measurements made at the soma should therefore be paired with estim
ates of the errors associated with these measurements. Such estimates
will require a knowledge of the location and kinetics for the synapse
under study as well as the electrotonic structure of the postsynaptic
neuron. The unclamped nature of remote synaptic events also raises the
possibility that voltage-gated channels in dendrites may be activated
by synaptic inputs, even under voltage-clamp conditions.