Am. Schott et al., ULTRASOUND MEASUREMENTS ON OS CALCIS - PRECISION AND AGE-RELATED-CHANGES IN A NORMAL FEMALE-POPULATION, Osteoporosis international, 3(5), 1993, pp. 249-254
We performed ultrasound measurements in the calcaneus of 512 healthy w
omen. Broadband ultrasonic attenuation (BUA) and speed of sound (SOS)
were obtained with a Lunar Achilles ultrasonic instrument. Subjects st
udied were one group of 67 women working in our hospital (group A) and
two groups which are part of two large prospective cohort studies (gr
oups B and C). Group B consisted of 244 women aged 31-79 years randoml
y selected from a large insurance company, and group C consisted of 20
1 women aged 74-91 years randomly selected from the electoral rolls. D
ual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) measurements of femoral neck and
total body were performed with a Hologic QDR 2000 for group B and wit
h a Lunar DPX Plus for group C. The in vitro precision of the Achilles
, estimated by measuring a phantom daily for 45 days, was 0.84% for BU
A and 0.12% for SOS. We assessed the in vivo short-term precision in 2
0 healthy volunteers working at the hospital, measured three times eac
h. The coefficients of variation were 0.93% (+/-0.21) for BUA and 0.15
% (+/-0.03) for SOS. The precision error was compared with the true va
riation, to obtain a standardized coefficient of variation. We analyse
d the three groups pooled together (n=512) and found for BUA an averag
e 20% decrease and for SOS a 5% decrease between the ages of 20 and 90
years. We also performed separate analyses of subjects younger than 5
0 and older than 50 years, and within each 10-year age group we found
that BUA was stable or slightly increased from 20 to 50 years and then
decreased after 50. In contrast, SOS did not increase but decreased f
rom the age of 20. We compared DXA measurements of the femoral neck an
d the total body with ultrasound measurements in groups B and C. In bo
th groups the correlations were better with total body DXA than with f
emoral neck and spine DXA.