Although spinal motoneurons in the chick embryo are born in a rostro-c
audal gradient, the timing of their naturally occurring cell death var
ies in the opposite sense: brachial motoneurons (MNs) die later than l
umbar MNs. We used in vitro methods to determine whether this differen
ce results from factors intrinsic or extrinsic to the MNs. Embryonic M
Ns were purified from E5 lumbar and brachial spinal cord by a method t
hat enriches for MNs with heightened trophic requirements; they were c
ultured in serum-free medium. In the absence of muscle extract. death
of both populations was rapid; similar results are obtained in ovo aft
er limb ablation. In the presence of muscle extracts, however, lumbar
MNs always died more rapidly than brachial MNs, as in the normal embry
o. We tested the ability of wing and leg bud extracts to provide troph
ic factors for MNs in culture. MNs from a given level responded equall
y well to wing or leg extracts. However, dose-response studies showed
that near-maximal survival of brachial MNs was obtained with lower con
centrations of limb extract than those required for optimal survival o
f lumbar MNs. These results suggest that the delayed apoptosis in the
brachial MN population is not a result of differing peripheral trophic
support, but is intrinsically programmed, at least partially through
a higher sensitivity to trophic factors.