The authors examined thyrotropin-releasing hormone (TRH) stimulation t
esting in the neuroendocrine evaluation of DSM-III major depressive di
sorder in 26 consecutive medication-free, medically healthy patients m
eeting a primary DSM-III diagnosis of axis II personality disorder. Th
yroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) responses to TRH challenge were not si
gnificantly different between patients with or without major depressio
n at time of study, or between patients with or without a life history
of major affective disorder. Further, TSH responses to TRH among 11 h
ealthy male nonpsychiatric controls were not significantly different f
rom those in patients with personality disorders. Comparison of those
patients with blunted TSH responses (<7.0 muU/ml) versus those without
blunted response (less-than-or-equal-to 7.0 muU/ml) also did not reve
al a significant difference. In addition, the TSH response to TRH did
not correlate with dimensional assessments of state or trait depressio
n, anxiety, or with past history of suicide attempt or alcohol abuse.
These data suggest that TRH stimulation testing has limited utility in
the evaluation of major depression or other relevant affective states
/traits in personality-disordered patients. Affective symptoms in pers
onality-disordered patients do not seem to be associated with dysregul
ation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-thyroid axis.