Compared with pure metals and ionic salts, covalent solids such as sil
icon are hard and brittle because dislocations do not move in them exc
ept at high temperatures. A satisfactory explanation for this behavior
has been lacking in spite of its great importance for the mechanics o
f materials and structures. It is shown here that the critical atomic
process leading to the observed brittleness is analogous to a chemical
substitution reaction. Analysis of this analogy with the aid of a cor
relation diagram yields the observed high resistive stress and high ac
tivation energy. When a kink on a dislocation line moves, it breaks th
e atomic bonding symmetry, a forbidden process.