Fm. Richter et Kk. Turekian, SIMPLE-MODELS FOR THE GEOCHEMICAL RESPONSE OF THE OCEAN TO CLIMATIC AND TECTONIC FORCING, Earth and planetary science letters, 119(1-2), 1993, pp. 121-131
Simple models for the geochemical response of the ocean to periodic fo
rcing are used as a framework to discuss the shortest periods of chang
e resolvable by present analytical precision of elemental or isotopic
ratio measurements of the chemical evolution of seawater. For chemical
properties whose budget is dominated by fluxes into and out of the oc
ean, we show that the geochemical response to changing fluxes is stron
gly attenuated at periods shorter than the residence time, and that th
e response at these periods is also phase shifted so as to lag the for
cing by one quarter cycle. The amplitude response as a function of per
iod is used to estimate the periods of forcing resolvable by present a
nalytical precision in measuring the Sr-87/Sr-86 and U-234/U-238 evolu
tion of seawater, and we find that the shortest periods resolvable are
of the order of 1 myr. If variations at periods shorter than this are
found, we would argue that these are very likely of local, as opposed
to global, origin. We illustrate the importance of phase shifts as a
function of forcing period by discussing some recently published data
that show a high degree of correlation (over the last 300 kyr) between
changes in Sr-87/Sr-86 and deltaO-18 measured in the same sediment co
re. At first sight this correlation might be taken as good evidence th
at both Sr-87/Sr-86 and deltaO-18 are responding to some common climat
ic forcing, but given the long residence time of Sr in the ocean, Sr a
nd O should in fact have different phase shifts relative to any propos
ed common forcing. Thus the apparent correlation between Sr-87/Sr-86 a
nd deltaO-18 over the past several 100 Ma is not necessarily an indica
tion that they are responding to a common cause. Amplitude response cu
rves are also used to place limits on permissible global seawater U-23
4/U-238 variations, and these are then compared with published data to
identify local (diagenetic) effects. Application to Os-187/Os-186 and
U records in seawater detectors is proposed.