Ethnographic research in the central Aravalli Hills of Rajasthan docum
ents a coherent system of groundwater irrigation distinctively differe
nt from the system of dams, wiers, and perennial canals redesigned for
India by the British during the early nineteenth century and continue
d by contemporary Indian governments. This paper articulates these ind
igenous principles and practices and contrasts them with those found i
n the scholarly literature on irrigation in Rajasthan which follows mo
dem engineering concerns. Our analysis indicates a difference set of q
uestions to guide future research on surface impoundments and groundwa
ter management. Furthermore, this study has broader implications for a
n understanding of the human-shaped hydrology of northwestern India, w
here the earlier system has been overlaid, but not fully displaced by
subsequent irrigation projects. Indeed, indigenous practices involving
groundwater recharge and retrieval may have continued to flourish and
expand, achieving a new order of hydrologic and adaptive complexity,
through the local initiative of the peasantry to adapt to the unintend
ed spillage, soakage, and siltage from the grand system of dams and pe
rennial canals constructed by the state.