Sj. Mckenzie et al., EFFECTS OF SETTING AND NUMBER OF OBSERVATIONS ON GENERALIZABILITY OF PARENT-CHILD INTERACTIONS IN CHILDHOOD OBESITY TREATMENT, Journal of psychopathology and behavioral assessment, 15(2), 1993, pp. 129-139
The generalizability of behaviors across observational conditions is a
critical issue in behavioral assessment. Generalizability theory was
used to examine two aspects of audio recorded parent-child interaction
s recorded over 6 days of home measurement and 1 day of laboratory mea
surement in a behavioral treatment program for childhood obesity. Fami
lies audiotaped parent-child home meetings during which they reviewed
self-monitored diet and exercise records that were coded for the follo
wing types of interactions: praise statements, negative statements, pr
ompts for new behaviors, and statements promoting problem solving. A s
imilar meeting was audiotaped in our laboratory. The first question ex
plored was the number of measurements needed to generalize to the univ
erse of the six home measures. Results showed an increase in generaliz
ability over measurements for each behavioral category. Using generali
zability coefficients of .60 or more, praise, negative comments and pr
ompts, respectively, could be reliably observed based on 1, 4, or 4 da
ys of measurement Second, the effects of setting (laboratory versus ho
me) were assessed for 1 day of measurement in each environment. Again
using generalizability coefficients of .60, generalizability analysis
showed that the lab setting could not be generalized to the home setti
ng based on 1 day of measurement, with generalizability coefficients r
anging from .27 for negative comments to.57 for praise. Results sugges
t that 4 days of behavioral assessment in the home can be used to esta
blish generalizable data for all the dependent measures studied. Howev
er, generalizability coefficients suggested that 1 day of laboratory m
easurement was not adequate to generalize to typical home behavior.