NUTRITION INTERVENTION TRIALS IN LINXIAN, CHINA - MULTIPLE VITAMIN MINERAL SUPPLEMENTATION, CANCER INCIDENCE, AND DISEASE-SPECIFIC MORTALITY AMONG ADULTS WITH ESOPHAGEAL DYSPLASIA
Jy. Li et al., NUTRITION INTERVENTION TRIALS IN LINXIAN, CHINA - MULTIPLE VITAMIN MINERAL SUPPLEMENTATION, CANCER INCIDENCE, AND DISEASE-SPECIFIC MORTALITY AMONG ADULTS WITH ESOPHAGEAL DYSPLASIA, Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 85(18), 1993, pp. 1492-1498
Background: A number of vitamins and minerals have been shown to influ
ence carcinogenesis in experimental animals. In humans, epidemiologic
evidence suggests that intake of fruits and vegetables may reduce risk
of esophageal and other cancers. Vitamins and minerals in these foods
may contribute to the reduced cancer risk. The people of Linxian, Chi
na, have persistently low intake of multiple nutrients and exhibit one
of the world's highest rates of esophageal/gastric cardia cancer, wit
h an exceptionally high risk of esophageal dysplasia. Purpose: To dete
rmine whether supplementation with multiple vitamins and minerals may
reduce esophageal/gastric cardia cancer among persons with esophageal
dysplasia, we conducted a 6-year prospective intervention trial in Lin
xian. Methods: Mortality and cancer incidence were ascertained from Ma
y 1985 through May 1991 for 3318 persons with cytologic evidence of es
ophageal dysplasia who were randomly assigned to receive, throughout t
hat period, daily supplementation with 14 vitamins and 12 minerals or
placebo. Doses were typically two to three times U.S. Recommended Dail
y Allowances. Compliance was assessed by counting unused pills monthly
for all trial participants and by assaying nutrient levels in blood c
ollected from samples of individuals randomly selected without replace
ment every 3 months throughout the trial. Cancers were identified thro
ugh routine surveillance and by special cytology and endoscopy screeni
ngs after 21/2 years and 6 years. Results: A total of 324 deaths occur
red during the 6-year intervention period; 167 occurred in the control
(placebo) group and 157 occurred in the supplement group. Cancer was
the leading cause of death (54% of all deaths); 18% were due to cerebr
ovascular diseases and 29% to other causes. Cumulative esophageal/gast
ric cardia death rates were 8% lower (relative risk [RR] = 0.92; 95% c
onfidence interval [CI] = 0.67-1.28) among individuals receiving suppl
ements rather than placebo, a nonsignificant (P>.10) difference. Risk
of total mortality was 7% lower (RR = 0.93; 95% CI = 0.75-1.16; P>.10)
, total cancer 4% lower (RR = 0.96; 95% CI = 0.71-1.29; P>.10), cerebr
ovascular disease 38% lower (RR = 0.62; 95% CI = 0.37-1.06; P = .08),
and other diseases 12% higher (RR = 1.12; 95% CI = 0.74-1.69; P>.10) a
mong the treated group. Cumulative cancer incidence rates were nearly
the same in the two groups. Conclusions: No substantial short-term ben
eficial effect on incidence or mortality for this type of cancer occur
red following daily supplementation with multiple vitamins and mineral
s among adults with precancerous lesions of the esophagus. Implication
s: Although no statistically significant short-term benefits were obse
rved, longer follow-up should be more informative about the effectiven
ess of this 6-year supplementation on cancer and other diseases among
individuals with esophageal dysplasia.