Eighty-five patients with squamous cell cancer of the maxillary sinus
received all of their treatment at The University of Texas M. D. Ander
son Cancer Center between the years 1971 and 1986. Their records were
evaluated according to stage, disease at presentation, symptoms and si
gns at presentation, treatment, and outcome. There were no differences
in locoregional control or survival between groups treated with surge
ry alone vs surgery plus radiotherapy. Careful analysis of the data in
dicates that there was almost certainly some selection bias for the pa
tients undergoing combination therapy, as most of this group had histo
rically adverse prognostic factors identified. Those patients who unde
rwent radiotherapy alone or chemotherapy presented with either metasta
tic or locally advanced disease and were treated with palliative inten
t; therefore, comparison between this group and standard therapy group
s was impossible in this retrospective review. Although it is tempting
to speculate that combination therapy improved locoregional control a
nd survival in patients with more advanced disease, none of the data p
resented in this review reach statistical significance. Furthermore, t
here is no difference in survival in this population compared with a s
tudy at this institution 20 years ago. Squamous cell cancer of the max
illary sinus continues to be a challenging neoplasm. Radiotherapy may
improve locoregional control and survival in a group of patients with
more advanced disease and may have its greatest utility in earlier-sta
ge disease. A multi-institutional prospective trial is needed to find
ways to improve outcome in this patient population.