From 1975 to 1984, 134 consecutive lateral tibial plateau fractures we
re treated as part of this prospective study. Eighty-six fractures (64
%) were followed until union, with an average follow-up period of 22.7
months. The two aims of this study were: First, to analyze the result
s of operative and nonoperative therapy in each fracture type, and sec
ond, to evaluate the effect of early weight bearing in a cast brace in
both types of treatment. All lateral tibial plateau fractures with gr
eater than 5 mm depression or displacement were treated operatively. F
orty-four patients were treated operatively and 42 patients nonoperati
vely. All patients were treated with early range of motion and weight
bearing in a cast brace. Fractures were initially classified using Hoh
l's classification system. Overall, 95% of the patients with Type I, I
I, or V fractures had satisfactory results, as opposed to only 70% of
patients with Type III fractures. Of the Type III fractures, 83% treat
ed operatively had satisfactory results compared with 53% treated nono
peratively. Moreover, early weight bearing did not produce further dep
ression greater than 2 mm.