The question discussed in this paper is whether effective dose can ref
lect the risk to patients from radiological procedures and can be used
, for example, to optimise procedures and compare risks of various met
hods, to define dose constraints, and to estimate the risks to individ
uals or populations attributed to medical exposures. This report demon
strates that the use of effective dose for patients could be misleadin
g or even wrong due to inappropriate simplifications of the underlying
biological mechanisms and inappropriateness of the weighting factors
connected with the definition of effective dose for a given patient po
pulation. We show that the choice of the most meaningful quantities to
express patient exposure depends strongly on the respective situation
.