'Nurse Triage' refers to the formal process of early assessment of pat
ients attending an accident and emergency (A&E) department by a traine
d nurse, to ensure that they receive appropriate attention, in a suita
ble location, with the requisite degree of urgency. The benefits claim
ed for nurse triage include better patient outcomes, through clinical
management reaching those in greatest need of it first. A recent study
of nurse triage in a British A&E department failed to demonstrate the
benefits claimed: patients undergoing triage were delayed, especially
those in the most urgent groups. No differences were noted between th
e two study groups in levels of satisfaction with the A&E process. The
results brought forth criticism from all quarters. In this paper the
points made by the critics are considered, and an attempt to answer th
em is made.