Joesmithite is a complex clinoamphibole which contains at least 14 com
ponents in its formula. Its ideal formula would be PbCa2Mg3Fe23+(Si6Be
2O22)(OH)2. It is monoclinic holosymmetric, an ordered derivative of t
he C2/m clinoamphiboles, a = 9.915(2), b = 17.951(4), c = 5.243(1)angs
trom, beta = 105.95(2)degrees, Z = 2, space group P2/a, D(obs) = 3.83(
1), D(cal) = 3.91 g cm-3. R = 0.056 for 2299 independent F0. The cells
of joesmithite and pargasitic amphibole were compared according to di
fferences, DELTA, in their structure cells. The same procedure was app
lied to the margarosanite, PbCa2Si3O9 and walstromite, BaCa2Si3O9 pair
s. In both pairs, the anion positions differed by 0.2 angstrom at most
, but the Pb/A, Pb/Ba differences ranged from 0.4 to 0.6 angstrom. The
lone pair Pb2+ cation responds according to the bond valence sums of
its coordinating anions compared with its closed core counterpart. It
appears that when the bond valence sums for the coordinating anions ar
e different, Pb2+ moves toward the most underbonded anion. If the anio
n bond valence sums are equal for all vertices of the coordinating pol
yhedron (as in wulfenite, Pb2+Mo6+O4), then Pb2+ does not shift.