Five species of columnar cati were examined with the aim of introducin
g new orchard crops to the Negev desert of Israel. The species compris
ed Stenocereus gummosus, S. griseus, S. thurberi and Pachycereus pring
lei, all found in semi-arid regions of Mexico, and Cereus peruvianus,
which is grown in sub-tropical regions. Young seedlings were planted a
t four sites in the Negev. The sites differ in climatic conditions and
water quality Growth data, expressed as total stem length and stem bi
omass, was obtained after five to six years in the orchards. They show
ed that C. peruvianus grew best in the site with moderate temperatures
and good-quality water, whereas the other species also did well under
more extreme conditions of high temperatures and brackish water. Grow
th of all species was significantly retarded at the site having water
with the highest NaCl content. In the sixth year a severe drop in temp
erature at one of the sites caused extensive injury to C. peruvianus a
nd S. griseus plants, raising doubts as to the suitability of that sit
e for their cultivation. At this stage C. peruvianus is the most promi
sing candidate for domestication. Its growth rate was much higher than
that of the other species, yield was precocious and fruit of good qua
lity. Stem tissue ion concentrations (dry weight basis) showed that ac
cumulation of K+ was similar at all four sites and that Na+ and Cl- we
re significantly higher (probably in toxic concentrations) at the site
with the highest concentrations of Na+ and Cl- ions in the water. At
all sites Cl- concentration in C. peruvianus was much lower than that
in the other species indicating that the exclusion of Cl- from the ste
ms was not correlated to salt tolerance.