D. Franceschi et al., THE MANAGEMENT OF COMMON BILE-DUCT STONES IN PATIENTS UNDERGOING LAPROSCOPIC CHOLECYSTECTOMY, The American surgeon, 59(8), 1993, pp. 525-532
The management of suspected and/or unsuspected common bile duct (CBD)
stones in patients undergoing laparoscopic cholecystectomy (LC) is con
troversial. Decisions on whether to perform an open CBD exploration ve
rsus employing therapeutic options such as pre-operative/post-operativ
e endoscopic retrograde cholangiography (ERCP) or endoscopic duct expl
oration are polemic. To determine indications, timing, benefits, and p
otential morbidity of these approaches, we gathered data on 401 patien
ts undergoing LC within the last 18 months. Indications for preoperati
ve ERCP included jaundice (40%), dilated ducts (28%), elevated amylase
(19%) or alkaline phosphatase (21%), suspicion of CBD stones by ultra
sound (17%) and ''other'' (17%). Indications for postoperative ERCP we
re retained stones (33%) and CBD evaluation (67%). Indications for CBD
exploration included abnormal cholangiogram (64%), palpable stones (1
8%), and other (18%). A significant correlation was observed between s
uspected stones by ultrasound and stones found by ERCP (P < 0.01). For
patients in the ''other'' category, preoperative ERCP was universally
negative (P = 0.04). Overall ERCP morbidity was 4/59 (6.8%), and the
overall failure rate for clearing CBD stones was 2/28 (7.1%). The timi
ng of the ERCP did not affect morbidity/mortality. Multivariate analys
is revealed that age (P << 0.001), the presence of pre-existing medica
l risk factors (P << 0.001), and duration of LC (P = 0.0034), but not
ERCP (P = 0.08), were the important factors determining LC morbidity.
In summary, common bile duct stones can be successfully cleared endosc
opically in the majority of patients undergoing LC. Patients with susp
ected CBD stones should undergo preoperative ERCP, and strict criteria
should be applied in the selection of these patients. Patients with s
ilent stones discovered during LC should be considered for postoperati
ve ERCP. Pre-/post- ERCP are safe therapeutic options in patients with
suspected/corroborated CBD stones who are undergoing LC. In patients
who are converted to an open procedure, CBD exploration remains the go
ld standard.