Two mechanisms for an aldose-ketose isomerization have been examined u
sing high level ab initio and semiempirical molecular orbital methods.
The proton transfer pathway via an enediol intermediate is shown to b
e favored in the absence of a metal ion, while the hydride transfer pa
thway becomes favored in the presence of a metal ion. Our calculations
explain why the proton transfer pathway is operative in most aldose-k
etose isomerization reactions. These calculations also provide further
support for the previously proposed metal ion-mediated hydride transf
er mechanism for xylose isomerase.