Lj. Stalans, CITIZENS CRIME STEREOTYPES, BIASED RECALL, AND PUNISHMENT PREFERENCESIN ABSTRACT CASES - THE EDUCATIVE ROLE OF INTERPERSONAL SOURCES, Law and human behavior, 17(4), 1993, pp. 451-470
Although researchers have noted the importance of understanding how pe
ople form punishment preferences about abstract criminal cases, few st
udies have examined this issue. Using both experimental and survey dat
a, two processes, reliance on an availability heuristic and reliance o
n a crime stereotype, contributed to punishment preferences. The findi
ngs suggest that the biased recall of severe crimes fuels demands for
harsher punishment in opinion polls, and that unstable, uninformed opi
nions partly produce the demands for harsher punishment. These studies
also found that information about crime from interpersonal sources ca
n change media driven, unrealistic crime stereotypes and substantially
reduce the biased recall of atypical, severe crimes reported in the m
ass media. Biased recall for more severe cases can be eliminated by in
cluding concrete or contextually distinct details in crime stories tha
t contain minor harm. These studies highlight the important role of co
ntext in punishment preferences and the important role that interperso
nal sources can play in educating the public about the nature of speci
fic offenses.