Et. Baker et al., A METHOD FOR QUANTITATIVELY ESTIMATING DIFFUSE AND DISCRETE HYDROTHERMAL DISCHARGE, Earth and planetary science letters, 118(1-4), 1993, pp. 235-249
Submarine hydrothermal fluids discharge as undiluted, high-temperature
jets and as diffuse, highly diluted, low-temperature percolation. Est
imates of the relative contribution of each discharge type, which are
important for the accurate determination of local and global hydrother
mal budgets, are difficult to obtain directly. In this paper we descri
be a new method of using measurements of hydrothermal tracers such as
Fe/Mn, Fe/heat, and Mn/heat in high-temperature fluids, low-temperatur
e fluids, and the neutrally buoyant plume to deduce the relative contr
ibution of each discharge type. We sampled vent fluids from the north
Cleft vent field on the Juan de Fuca Ridge in 1988, 1989 and 1991, and
plume samples every year from 1986 to 1991. The tracers were, on aver
age, 3 to 90 times greater in high-temperature than in low-temperature
fluids, with plume values intermediate. A mixing model calculates tha
t high-temperature fluids contribute only approximately 3% of the flui
d mass flux but > 90% of the hydrothermal Fe and > 60% of the hydrothe
rmal Mn to the overlying plume. Three years of extensive camera-CTD sl
ed tows through the vent field show that diffuse venting is restricted
to a narrow fissure zone extending for 18 km along the axial strike.
Linear plume theory applied to the temperature plumes detected when th
e sled crossed this zone yields a maximum likelihood estimate for the
diffuse heat flux of 8.9 X 10(4) W/m, for a total flux of 534 MW, cons
idering that diffuse venting is active along only one-third of the fis
sure system. For mean low- and high-temperature discharge of 25-degree
s-C and 319-degrees-C, respectively, the discrete heat flux must be 26
6 MW to satisfy the mass flux partitioning. If the north Cleft vent fi
eld is globally representative, the assumption that high-temperature d
ischarge dominates the mass flux in axial vent fields leads to an over
estimation of the flux of many non-conservative hydrothermal species b
y about an order of magnitude.