Ws. Judd et Ka. Kron, CIRCUMSCRIPTION OF ERICACEAE (ERICALES) AS DETERMINED BY PRELIMINARY CLADISTIC ANALYSES BASED ON MORPHOLOGICAL, ANATOMICAL, AND EMBRYOLOGICAL FEATURES, Brittonia, 45(2), 1993, pp. 99-114
Cladistic analyses of selected taxa of Ericaceae an potential relative
s) suggest that the family, as traditionally circumscribed, is paraphy
letic. The traditionally recognized groups, Monotropaceae, Pyrolaceae,
Epacridaceae, and Empetraceae, are nested within the cladistic struct
ure of Ericaceae, and it seems reasonable to expand the circumscriptio
n of the latter. Preliminary analyses suggest that Actinidia (Actinidi
aceae) likely is cladistically basal within Ericales, with Cyrilla (Cy
rillaceae) and Clethra (Clethraceae) positioned, respectively, as seco
nd and first outgroups to Ericaceae. Generic relationships within Eric
aceae are highly unresolved due to extensive homoplasy, but Enkianthus
appears to be the sister group of the remaining ericad genera. The cu
rrent division of the family into five subfamilies, i.e., Rhododendroi
deae, Ericoideae, Vaccinioideae, Pyroloideae, and Monotropoideae, very
likely is not in accordance with phylogenetic relationships.