The gene Vf from Malus floribunda 821 for resistance to scab (Venturia
inaequalis), has been used successfully for 50 yr in apple breeding p
rograms. Since 1984, scab symptoms have been observed in the field at
Ahrensburg, Germany, on seedlings of apple cv. Prima that have been se
lected as resistant in the greenhouse. In 1988, small scab lesions wer
e found on some Vf selections in the same orchard. The inoculum from A
hrensburg was compared with the inoculum currently used at Angers, Fra
nce, for selecting apple seedlings for resistance to V. inaequalis. Al
l Vf gene cultivars or selections tested were susceptible to the Ahren
sburg inoculum, whereas M. floribunda 821 itself and the ornamental cr
abapple Evereste were resistant. The progeny from a cross between a re
sistant (Vf) and a susceptible cultivar segregate into the rive expect
ed classes to Angers inoculum, but were completely susceptible to Ahre
nsburg inoculum. These results indicate the urgency of diversifying th
e sources of resistance to V. inaequalis in new breeding strategies. T
he distinction should be made between the resistance of M. floribunda
821, which is resistant to Ahrensburg inoculum, and that of the named
cultivars and selections, which are susceptible. The new race of V. in
aequalis is named race 6.