F. Workneh et al., VARIABLES ASSOCIATED WITH CORKY ROOT AND PHYTOPHTHORA ROOT-ROT OF TOMATOES IN ORGANIC AND CONVENTIONAL FARMS, Phytopathology, 83(5), 1993, pp. 581-589
In 1989 and 1990, a comparative study of organic and conventional toma
to-production systems in the Central Valley of California was conducte
d to determine the effects of management practices on soil properties
and tomato diseases and to relate disease severity in tomatoes to vari
ous soil and plant variables. Twenty sampling locations were randomly
selected at each of nine (1989) and 18 (1990) farms to measure 10 soil
variables, plant biomass and nitrogen content, and incidence and seve
rity of Phytophthora root rot caused by Phytophthora parasitica and co
rky root caused by Pyrenochaeta lycopersici. P. parasitica was detecte
d by leaf bait assay in soil samples from five of the nine conventiona
l farms but not from organic farms, and Phytophthora root rot was obse
rved in three conventional farms only. Corky root was found on most pl
ants in most locations, but incidence and severity were higher in conv
entional than in organic farms. Corky root-severity values, estimates
of P. parasitica populations from the leaf bait assay, and Phytophthor
a root rot-severity values were grouped into three, two, and two class
es, respectively, for use in stepwise and canonical discriminant analy
ses with 11 variables. The distinction among three classes of corky ro
ot severity was consistently associated with three variables: tissue n
itrogen, soil nitrate, and nitrogen-mineralization potential. Nitrogen
in tomato tissue and nitrate concentration in soil were positively co
rrelated with corky root severity; nitrogen-mineralization potential w
as negatively correlated with this disease. Six soil variables (clay c
ontent, water-stable aggregates, soil-nitrate concentration, organic c
arbon, electrical conductivity, and soil-water content) contributed mo
st to variability in the presence of P. parasitica in soil. All variab
les except organic carbon were positively correlated with the presence
of P. parasitica in soil. Clay content and water-stable aggregates we
re also positively associated with Phytophthora root rot, and microbia
l activity was negatively associated with this disease.