Rs. Mansell et al., A TOOL FOR EVALUATING A NEED FOR VARIABLE SELECTIVITIES IN CATION-TRANSPORT IN SOIL, Water resources research, 29(6), 1993, pp. 1855-1858
The empirical Rothmund-Kornfeld equation was used to describe a collec
tion of cation exchange isotherms for K and Ca in Brucedale soil over
a range of total solution concentrations (C(T)). A comparison of varia
ble binary exchange selectivity coefficients (K(KCa)) which vary with
C(T) and solution phase ion concentrations (C(K), C(Ca)) With constant
K(KCa) values was thus possible. Percent differences between sorbed e
quilibrium concentrations calculated using variable and constant K(KCa
) over a range of C(T) and C(K) were arranged into a contour map. Zone
s of potentially observable difference were limited, implying that sim
ulations of cation transport using variable and constant K(KCa) values
would be essentially identical. The predicted effect was examined usi
ng a numerical model for cation transport. The model successfully desc
ribed observed spatial distributions for cation concentrations followi
ng constant-flux infiltration of electrolyte solution into soil column
s. Simulations using variable K(KCa) values provided only a slight imp
rovement over simulations using constant K(KCa) values, thus validatin
g the use of the contour map as a convenient method to evaluate the ne
ed to use variable selectivities in simulations of cation transport.